Perfection

Posted by Steve in the late evening on Friday the 2nd of November, 2007

Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away.

Antoine de Saint Exupéry, ‘Terre des Hommes’ (1939)

This sentiment is just as true for markup, style, and behaviour on the web. The trick, though, is to find the optimal balance between the four.

Markup

When building a page, one should assume nothing: mark it up in the most minimal, sparse way possible whilst still maintaining a logical structure.

No classes. No ids. No divs or spans. Just pure, semantically rich HTML elements.

Next, divide the page into major logical divisions using divs with apt ids. Use classes to identify patterns used throughout the page (cf. Microformats). At this stage, one should be adding semantic context as minimally as possible.

Further, this context should be added at the highest level in the DOM that is appropriate, and no higher. For example, an ordered list of blog posts should not feature a class of post on each list item; rather, the list itself should have the class posts.

Remove redundancy in all aspects of the markup. Consider different choices of elements, even if they seem unfit for purpose.

If, at the end of this process, it seems like the document should be easy to style accordingly then there are probably too many styling hooks, in the form of non-semantic classes, ids and elements, in place already. Go back and think about everything once more. Make every element and attribute justify its existence.

By this point all functionality of the page, be it part of an application or straight prose, should be exposed and fully usable.

All of it.

If there’s a single piece of functionality that you feel you can’t provide in raw HTML, you’re doing it wrong.

This doesn’t mean the interaction has to be as rich as it might be, but it should be usable.

Style

As with the markup, styling should be approached by using the most simple approaches possible to achieve the desired look.

The styling shouldn’t obfuscate any functionality: everything should still work as intended.

Avoid adding extra markup at all costs. If it seems that extra markup is necessary to aid styling, consider that the approach being used to acheive the style is the wrong one.

Behaviour

Finally, enhance the behaviour as necessary. As with styling, consider that the desire to add to the DOM (either before or during the life of a script) could be a sign that the solution is not the optimal one. Similarly, if styles must be added before any interaction occurs, separate them using some class high in the DOM tree.

If anything must be added, be they elements, ids, classes, or styles, add them at the latest possible instant and promptly remove them when unneeded. When applying behaviour use, as far as possible, already extant semantics for context.

Further, if the behaviour relies on styling to justify its existence, it may need rethinking.

Throughout all three, one should attempt to focus on the smallest area possible at a time. Break the document into its requisite parts, developing these in isolation from one another and the framework to bind them together.

Above all: if you’re not finding it hard, and agonising over it, you’re probably not doing it right.

Filed under

Something to say? Contact Steve (at journal@this domain) or link to this post from your blog.